All Nighter Is the Off-Broadway Play That Gets College Life Exactly Right

With AnnaSophia Robb and Isa Briones joining the cast, All Nighter delivers a sharp, hilarious, and emotionally resonant portrayal of college friendships under pressure.

Photo: All Nighter

If you've ever pulled an all-nighter in college—surrounded by empty Red Bull cans, half-eaten hummus tubs, and the looming dread of finals—you'll find a piece of yourself in All Nighter. This Off-Broadway gem, penned by Natalie Margolin, captures the chaos, camaraderie, and complexities of college life with uncanny precision. Now, with the addition of AnnaSophia Robb and Isa Briones, the play's dynamic ensemble brings even more depth to this 95-minute rollercoaster of emotions.

Who's in the "All Nighter" cast?

AnnaSophia Robb and Isa Briones step into the roles of Darcie and Lizzy, respectively, bringing fresh energy and nuanced performances to the stage. Robb's portrayal of Darcie, the overachiever with a facade of control, resonates with anyone who's ever tried to keep it all together while internally unraveling. Briones, as Lizzy, delivers a heartfelt performance that captures the anxiety and vulnerability of a student grappling with more than just academic pressures.

Their chemistry with the existing cast members is palpable, adding new layers to the already intricate web of relationships. Tony nominee Kathryn Gallagher brought both edge and empathy to the role of Jacqueline, while Julia Lester infused Wilma with warmth and HILARIOUS comic timing. Alyah Chanelle Scott’s portrayal of Tessa was a standout, effortlessly balancing biting humor with emotional depth. With AnnaSophia Robb and Isa Briones now stepping into the roles of Darcie and Lizzy—originally played by Kristine Frøseth and Havana Rose Liu—the production maintains its emotional core while gaining a fresh new spark from its updated ensemble.

Who wrote the "All Nighter" play?

Margolin's writing shines in its ability to balance humor with poignant moments. The dialogue is sharp, witty, and, most importantly, believable. It captures the way young adults communicate—the sarcasm, the passive-aggressiveness, the moments of unexpected sincerity. The script doesn't shy away from heavier topics like mental health and sexual assault, addressing them with the gravity they deserve while maintaining the play's overall rhythm.​

The authenticity of the script is further enhanced by the cast's delivery. Each line feels organic, as if the actors are drawing from personal experiences. This synergy between writing and performance creates a world that's both specific in its setting and universal in its themes.

Is "All Nighter" play worth going to see?

All Nighter is more than just a play; it's a reflection of a pivotal time in many people's lives. For those in or fresh out of college, the themes of friendship, identity, and the transition into adulthood will hit close to home. The play doesn't offer easy answers but instead presents a snapshot of a moment in time that's both fleeting and formative.​

The performances are compelling, the writing is insightful, and the production values are top-notch. Whether you're a recent graduate reminiscing about your college days or someone currently navigating that landscape, All Nighter offers a cathartic and entertaining experience.